Overview

The Secrets of Thistle Cottage by Kerry Barrett is a dual timeline novel set in a small Scottish village, where past and present are tightly entwined. The story follows a woman who retreats to Thistle Cottage after a difficult period in her life, only to uncover local stories linked to historic witchcraft accusations. Through old letters, village memories, and half buried truths, the novel explores how an injustice from centuries ago still shapes the present day.

Writing & Atmosphere

We found the writing easy to read and quick to settle into. The chapters move at a steady pace, often ending just when new information is revealed. The Scottish setting is a strong part of the book, with stone cottages, changing weather, and a close knit community that feels believable. The atmosphere leans gently towards gothic, but it stays cosy rather than dark.

Characters

The modern day main character is sympathetic and grounded, carrying much of the emotional weight of the story. In the historical timeline, the woman accused of witchcraft is given dignity and clarity, helping us understand how fear and rumour took hold. Supporting characters, from curious neighbours to a steady romantic interest, add warmth and tension without overcrowding the plot.

Themes

The book looks closely at how stories about women are shaped by fear, gossip, and power. Witchcraft is used as a way to examine how communities turn on those who stand out or refuse to conform. Memory, truth, and the need to speak openly about the past run through both timelines, linking the characters across centuries.

What Worked

• Clear dual timeline: the past and present sections are easy to follow and well balanced.
• Strong sense of place: the village setting feels familiar and convincing.
• Emotional focus: healing, trust, and belonging drive the story.

Minor Quibbles

• Some plot devices will feel familiar to regular readers of timeslip fiction.
• The romantic element follows a predictable path and softens the tension near the end.

Final Thoughts

We enjoyed The Secrets of Thistle Cottage for its warmth, clear storytelling, and thoughtful look at how the past lingers in small communities. It is a comforting read with a serious core, balancing mystery, history, and emotional repair.

Rating: ★★★½☆ (3.5/5)