Overview

We meet Corrag in a prison cell in 1692 Scotland, accused of witchcraft and waiting to die. A minister named Charles Leslie is sent to record her confession. Instead, Corrag tells him the story of her life in the Highlands, her deep bond with the land, and her witness to the brutal Glencoe Massacre. Through her voice, the novel becomes both a personal history and a quiet act of defiance.

Writing & Voice

We found Susan Fletcher’s writing gentle and immersive, shaped by landscape and feeling rather than plot twists. Corrag’s voice is simple but poetic, rooted in the natural world she loves. The chapters move between Corrag’s memories and the minister’s reflections, which helps ground the story and gives space for the reader to breathe.

Characters

Corrag is a powerful presence, assuming, deeply observant, and fiercely free in spirit even when imprisoned. Charles Leslie begins the book certain of his beliefs, but Corrag’s honesty slowly unsettles him. Their conversations form the emotional core of the novel, showing how understanding can grow even across fear and difference.

Themes

This is a novel about persecution and freedom, and about who gets to decide what is acceptable or dangerous. We see how fear of difference leads to cruelty, and how storytelling can become a form of survival. Nature plays a central role, offering Corrag a sense of truth and belonging that no prison can take away.

What Worked

• Sense of place: The Highlands feel vivid and alive on every page.
• Emotional restraint: The story trusts the reader and never overstates its pain.
• Memorable voice: Corrag stays with us long after the book ends.

Minor Quibbles

• The slow pace may challenge readers who prefer action driven historical fiction.
• The poetic style will not suit every taste.

Final Thoughts

We found Witch Light tender, haunting, and quietly brave. It is a story that listens to the past and gives voice to someone history tried to erase.

Rating: ★★★★½ (4.5/5)