Independent Scottish Bookshop

  Every book chosen by a bookseller.





Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars

  Independent Scottish Bookshop





Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
  Free Delivery on orders of £25+

Book Review: 1984 Nineteen Eighty-Four

Cover of 1984 by George Orwell - Scottish contemporary fiction
Buy 1984 Nineteen Eighty-Four

1984 Nineteen Eighty-Four

by · ISBN: 9781846975769
★★★★★
Fiction Classic Dystopian Political Fiction Surveillance State

Overview

We read 1984 as a bleak tale set in a future totalitarian world where the Party, led by Big Brother, controls every part of life. Winston Smith works rewriting history for the Ministry of Truth but dreams of freedom and rebellion. He falls for Julia and risks everything for truth and connection.

Writing & Voice

We found Orwell’s prose stark and brutal. His language is clear but laden with dread. Every detail reinforces the oppressive atmosphere. Orwell never softens the world he describes. The voice feels urgent and precise, forcing the reader to see the harshness of constant state surveillance.

Content & Perspective

The story follows Winston’s thoughts and small acts of defiance as he navigates a world of omnipresent monitoring and ruthless control. His internal struggle reveals the cost of seeking truth under a regime that criminalises independent thought and human connection.

Themes

This novel examines power, propaganda, and the erasure of truth. It shows how language and fear can be used to control people’s minds. It also explores isolation, resistance, and the high cost of defying a system built on surveillance and manipulation.

What Worked

  • Relentless worldbuilding that feels chillingly plausible.
  • Complex moral tension in Winston’s small acts of rebellion.
  • Clear, impactful prose that leaves a lasting impression.

Minor Quibbles

  • The bleakness may be too intense for some readers.
  • Certain institutional details feel dated now and then.

Final Thoughts

We think this remains one of the most powerful warnings about power and control, a story that challenges the reader to face uncomfortable truths about society and self.

Rating: ★★★★★ / 5

We recommend this to readers who like classic fiction that confronts big ideas about society, language, and human freedom.