Overview

The Polish Detective introduces Polish Detective Sergeant Dania Gorska, newly transferred to Dundee’s specialist crime division. Called to investigate a sequence of grotesque killings where victims are murdered and posed in bizarre ways, she soon suspects a link to a local druidic group and faces danger as clues mount.

Writing & Voice

We found Allen’s prose brisk and engaging, balancing the procedural urgency with Dania’s inner life. The voice is observant and grounded, bringing both Dundee’s urban rhythms and the detective’s outsider perspective into focus without slowing the plot.

Content & Perspective

The narrative follows Dania’s investigation as she navigates cultural gaps, forensic puzzles and mounting stakes. She becomes drawn to the disappearance of two teenage girls with ties to the same group as the murder victims, deepening the mystery and personal risk.

Themes

The novel explores alienation and belonging through a detective far from home, the human need to find meaning in violence, and how communities cope with fear and secrecy. It also examines how past beliefs and local history shape present threats.

What Worked

• Compelling central detective with depth and vulnerability.
• Atmospheric Dundee setting that feels lived-in.
• Tightly woven mystery with surprising turns.

Minor Quibbles

• Some plot elements lean on thriller conventions.
• Cultural references occasionally slow the pace.

Final Thoughts

The Polish Detective is a confident, atmospheric debut that drew us in with its central character, sharp pacing, and a mystery that kept us thoroughly engaged.

Rating: ★★★★½ / 5