Overview

Torch centres on a woman found burned to death in a remote area of Scotland. Forensic scientist Rhona MacLeod is drawn into a case that appears at first to be a clear act of violence, but soon links back to older events and unresolved questions. The investigation unfolds across time as past actions resurface.

Writing & Voice

We found Anderson’s writing calm, precise and confident. The procedural detail is carefully handled, allowing the story to build through method rather than shock. The tone remains controlled, giving weight to both the forensic work and the human cost behind the crime.

Content & Perspective

The novel balances present day investigation with the slow uncovering of earlier decisions and buried truths. We follow Rhona’s professional judgement while also seeing how memory, guilt and loyalty shape what witnesses choose to reveal or withhold.

Themes

Torch explores responsibility, secrecy and the long reach of violence. It asks how crimes echo forward through time and how justice is complicated when truth has been delayed. The book also reflects on endurance and the emotional toll of carrying unresolved cases.

What Worked

• A strong central investigation that unfolds with patience.
• Effective use of past and present to deepen tension.
• A grounded forensic perspective anchoring the story.

Minor Quibbles

• The pace is measured rather than urgent.
• Some emotional beats are deliberately restrained.

Final Thoughts

Quietly gripping and carefully paced, Torch impressed us with its patience, showing how old crimes linger and how truth emerges slowly through method, memory, and persistence.

Rating: ★★★★½ / 5